Peter Leibert's Page
|
MY
INDIA ADVENTURE – PART Prevention
of disability takes one to strange arenas - Brussels, Paris, Mexico City, Hong
Kong, Vancouver, Italy, and even to Wailuku on the Sandwich island of Maui.
But one has to do what he or she has to do.
By the time you read these words, my latest adventure will have long
before been completed - a trip to the mysterious and exciting India.
Any announcement of this new adventure brings one of three very distinct
reactions - “Why India?”, OR “India!
Oh, I’ve always wanted to go there!”, OR “Oh Pete, you’ll get
sick over there”. The purpose for
which I took such a trip to this Asian country was the “prevention of
disability” as I was traveling to attend the International League of Societies
for Persons with Mental Handicap (ILSMH) conference in the India capital city of
New Delhi. During this 1994 session, the ILSPMH organization had
included a sub-program about primary prevention. I
had been requested to participate in a number of sessions about preventing
mental retardation. One conference
I attended concerned brain injury. This
meeting was held in the city of Bangalore in southern India, so I got to see
different parts of India. I
had been preparing for this challenging experience by reading a lot about India,
both in books, and more recently within the press.
The writings within most of the books I had read leave you with the
impression that India is swamped with health problems.
“Millions of their peoples have an extremely low standard of living,
often are unable to afford nourishing food, can get little clean or pure water,
and usually live in extremely poor housing”.
The
book authors report that there are limited education opportunities, job
shortages, and natural disasters. Some
of the newer books do speak of projects to develop water and sewage systems, of
building new housing and new hospitals, of developing modern technical training
programs, of drives to eliminate mosquitoes, and to control contagious disease
via vaccination programs. One
textbook reported that during the early 1970’s, India had a high death rate of
infants occurring in their first year of life. (This rate was about 150 per
1,000 live births. Infant mortality
was over 200 per 1,000 during the 1910-1915 period.) During
the 1970’s, the death rate dropped rapidly to about 12.5 per 1,000 among one-
to four-year-olds. During that same
time frame, the average Indian, when born, could be expected to live roughly 50
to 55 years. These
authors saw this as a tremendous improvement as life expectancy had risen
dramatically throughout the century from a scant 20 years in the 1910-1915
period. There were a number of
endemic communicable diseases that are continual public health hazards.
A variety of national prevention programs exist aimed at controlling or
eradicating disease. The
National Malaria Eradication Programme, the National Programme for the Control
of Blindness, and the National Filaria Parasite Programme were examples.
Other
programs sought to limit the incidence of cholera, diarrheal disease, trachoma,
goiter, and sexually transmitted diseases.
Government goals are to reduce the death rate to nine per 1,000, drop
infant mortality below 60 per 1,000 live births, and raise life expectancy to 64
years by the year 2,000. Health
care facilities and personnel have increased substantially since the early
1950’s. By the early 1980’s,
there were approximately seven hospital beds and four physicians per 10,000
individuals. In
today’s environment, the media has been reporting daily about the steps being
taken in the panicked cities of India as pneumonic
plague has stuck. Pneumonic
plague is one of the three forms of the feared pestilence known in the Middle
Ages as the “Black Death”. In
the 14th century, plague killed about one-fourth the population of Europe. As a prevention advocate, this seems to be a wonderful opportunity to learn first hand about life in a country struggling with the many problems of basic survival. MY
INDIA A
DVENTURE – PAR As
I reported in the last issue, the World Health Organization had reported that
pneumonic plague was taking a toll of human life in India.
This was occurring a few months before my departure for India.
One of two conferences I was scheduled to attend was canceled for about a
week and then in mid October reinstated. This
is a continuing tale of my saga. Plague
is spread to humans by fleas that have bitten rats infected with the bacillus
Yersinia pestis (formerly called Pasteurella pestis). It occurs in several forms.
Bubonic
plague, the most common, causes swollen lymph glands. In its pneumonic form, the infection leads to high fever, the
vomiting of blood and the filling of the lungs with fluid.
Without treatment, death almost always occurs within 2 to 4 days.
Even with treatment, mortality is still about 20%. The
plague returned to India for the first time in 28 years this August when a
village in the Bir district, in the state of Maharashtra, reported its first
case of bubonic plague. The
outbreak was blamed on a surge in the rat population drawn by relief food meant
to help victims of last year’s destructive earthquake.
Bir is about 200 miles east of Bombay which is midway on the west coast
of India. More
than 90 people were infected in the Bir area, but the bubonic outbreak was
brought under control by insecticide spraying (DDT) and antibiotics
(tetracycline, chloram-phenicol, or kanamycin). A
month later, an outbreak of the more serious pneumonic plague occurred in the
city of Surat. Surat is located in
the state of Gujarat about 120 miles north of Bombay. About a week after the announcement of the plague being found
in Surat, about 400,000 of the city’s 2 million people made a panicky exodus.
Pneumonic
plague symptoms usually develop within one to six days after exposure to the
plague bacillus. As symptoms
develop, an infected individual can pass the plague-causing bacterium, Yersinia
pestis, to others through droplets in the air from coughs or sneezes. Partly
because of the Surat residents fleeing, fear that the disease would scattered across India became widespread,
and also impacted public health systems outside the borders of India.
A number of countries banned flights to and from the country. Within
India, the government urged calm and stepped up efforts to find the sick, rush
antibiotics to pharmacies, and spray insecticide to kill disease-carrying fleas
and rats. New Delhi, where the
ILSMH conference is to be held, had about 20 suspected cases admitted to their
hospitals. Most of them had fled to
New Delhi from Surat. Two died.
Hospitals reported suspected plague cases in Maharashtra, Rajasthan,
Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Orissa, and Tamil Nadu, some of the largest
states in this nation of 900 million. To
help prevent plague, the Indian officials are recommending that travelers avoid
areas with recently reported human plague cases. To prevent getting the plague, persons are being told to
avoid rat-infested areas, apply insect repellents to ankles and legs, and apply
repellents and insecticides to clothing and other bedding. MY
INDIA ADVENTURE – PAR Traveling
half way around the world is an experience in itself, especially with the jet
lag effects upsetting your system and your plans. India brings to one an expanded understanding of the
struggles that many people are facing every day just to survive, but it also
induces an excitement of learning about the beauty and happiness of a
distinctive people and culture. These
words attempt to describe the fleeting impressions I have retained from my trip
to the Indian cities of Bangalore, Mysore, New Delhi and Agra. After
36 hours of travel time, it does feel great to have your feet on the ground
again. Riding in any car in
the city of Delhi brightens your senses. There
are no seat belts in any of the vehicles, and the drivers act like they don’t
want to lose a race to somewhere. The
drivers physically “take” the road apparently ignoring other cars,
motorcycles, bicycles, pedestrians, and animals — yes, animals. They are mostly the cattle-like Brahman.
Since my arrival was at two in the morning, these animals were seen
resting at roadside, but sometimes their resting spot was in the middle of the
street itself. Hazards,
by my standards, include no tail lights, which I noticed on a large percentage
of the vehicles. This was typical
for the three-wheeled autorickshaws that abound everywhere even at two AM in the
morning. In Delhi, bicycles are a
frequently used means of transportation. My
early observations recorded no indications of lights nor reflectors on that type
of vehicle. Much to my surprise,
the drivers of the numerous motorcycles and motor scooters
were wearing safety helmets on their heads.
However, their passengers were not. Quite noticeable was the smog.
I was informed that November was the peak of the smoggy season and that
Delhi was the smoggiest city in the world.
Almost all of the vehicles use diesel fuel, and there does not seem to be
any requirement for vehicle smog controls.
Faulty fuel injectors were very obvious to this former test engineer as I
observed heavy black smoke being emitted from 90% of these diesel motors.
This is in addition to the smoke coming from burning leaves and trash,
and to the dust. Los Angeles was
never like this with the exception of the times when they used to burn oil in
our citrus smudge pots years ago. First
impressions about the hotel were great as the marble-walled lobby was similar to
the better class hotels found in the United States.
The elevator was a clue that all was not as it first seemed, since the
operation of the hoisting machinery that Mr. Otis invented was marginal at best.
It did stop at the right floor, plus or minus a few inches. “Lack of routine maintenance” was my judgment.
At the time, all I could think of was the elevator in the movie
“Hotel”. My
youngest son would have had a field day if he had seen the hallway carpets - he
enjoys life by being a salesman for Philadelphia Carpets, a division of Shaw
Industries (an unpaid advertisement). I
am certain Steve could have convinced the hotel owners that a new carpet would
be a good investment and would increase repeat business.
(Perhaps not, as I later learned that the hotel was owned by the
government and I hadn’t been in any of their bathrooms yet). The
eloquent highlight of my emotions was reached when I realized that the bathroom
plumbing in my room did not use what I consider to be a basic prevention tool
for the drains of bathroom fixtures. This
was typical of all bathrooms and rest room’s I utilized while in the country.
Instead of the water trap below the sink, I found moth balls in
the sink. Odors
may be covered up and moths may be deterred by these little naphthalene balls,
but small bugs are not. Almost
every evening I slew a cricket or some other small “bug” that had probably
climbed the walls of the plumbing in order to reach my 9th floor room. It
may seem that I am picking on the negatives from my trip, and perhaps I am.
This should not be what you use to judge whether or not to visit India.
I would probably do the same if I were to review my impressions of
California. There
were a lot positives. The people of
India proved to be a very friendly lot. Most
adults were very responsive to a smile or a wave or a camera, but the children
were especially so. On a couple of
occasions I became surrounded by twenty-five or more school kids wanting their
picture to be taken with the “strange” visitor.
While touring the Lodi Hindu temple in Delhi, I found myself in great
demand as a model as part of family pictures with their white-bearded guest from
the United States. I and others
received many personal invites to visit the homes of newly found friends. The
food we received at our conferences was very,
very tasty, but a little too much sameness. This might have
been caused by the curry-based sauces found on almost all of the
“vegetarian” and “non-vegetarian” dishes.
Hindus do not eat meat, so vegetarian meals were found everywhere in the
region including on the airlines coming to and fro.
Whoever
selected our convention menus must have loved ice cream.
It was offered at every meal. It
was also quite interesting that the meals were served in rooms that had no
tables and very few places to sit down. Fingers
were the preferred utensil, it appeared.
I
took a side trip to Agra. Many
people merely visit Delhi to reach Agra, which is the medieval home for the
“famous” Taj Mahal. Agra is 126
miles from Delhi which a trip that is another story in its own right. (If you would like learn about this trip, send me an E-mail
message and I’ll forward you everything you never wanted to hear about
traveling to Agra). The
Taj Mahal was worth taking that exciting trip.
The Taj Mahal is just like the postcards. This must be India’s most loved tourist attraction and I
agree that it is “a very enduring symbol of love and historic beauty”.
The structure was completed in 1659 after 21 years of construction by
some 20,000 laborers. Akbar The
Great, made Agra great. Nearly
all the world’s great monuments were the product of the religious fervor of a
people or the vanity of a king. But
the Taj Mahal is an exception; it was built as a monument to love.
The woman was Arjuman Banu and the man was Shah Jahan.
They were married in 1621. Arjuman
in the next nine years bore 14 children and it was in childbirth that she died
in 1630. Her husband was grief
stricken. He then vowed to build
her a memorial surpassing anything the world had ever seen in beauty and in wild
extravagance. He brought in skilled
craftsmen from France, Italy, Persia, and Turkey. The cost of reproducing the Taj Mahal today has been
estimated at nearly $70 million. A
side trip in southern India was to see a district health center.
The site we visited was about 25 miles outside of Bangalore and was quite
busy the day we were there. It
serves about 26,000 residents and many of them must have had a baby this year.
There was a long line of mothers carrying babies awaiting to get
vaccinations for tuberculosis and measles.
We were told that rubella was unheard of in India. The
center consisted of three buildings with very, very, little in the way of
furniture or equipment. Most of the
examining tables were of the homemade variety.
Their pride and joy was a relatively new halfsize refrigerator which
housed the vaccine. Records
were displayed on some of the walls showing the numbers of people seen by month
during the year 1993 and the 1994 year-to-date. Their targets for 1994 included vaccinating 700 persons, and
it appeared that they had already attained their annual targets.
India’s health department has a goal of achieving 100% immunity to the
common childhood diseases by the year 2000. One
feature of this health center program was their maternal nutrition education
classes. Small groups of these
mothers are taken aside and given a short session on the need to eat a balanced
diet. This occurred each visit
during pregnancy and continued as part of their well baby visits.
Samples of the recommended foods were displayed and various low cost, but
nutritious, recipes were shared. Although
India grows enough food for its population, making sure that low income pregnant
women eat enough of the right types of foods is a major problem.
One third of the babies in India are born smaller that 2500 grams (low
birth weight by US standards). In
many “developed” countries, LBW runs less than 10% of live births and is
closely linked to the babies that are delayed in their development.
At a later visit to the Victoria Hospital in Bangalore I saw dozens of
VERY LBW babies, all weighing less than 1500 grams. From
the poor sections, we went to the palaces where the royalty of old used to spend
the peoples money. Here, one week
after my arrival in India, we were treated to our first sit down meal at the
former Chamundi Hill palace, now a fancy hotel. Mysore is a city of palaces, gardens, and Oriental splendor.
In
Mysore, there is little evidence of the crushing poverty so often associated
with India. The Maharaja’s palace
is the most impressive building in the area and was built less than 100 years
ago. Pictures on its walls depict
the pomp, grandeur, and ceremony that occurred there during the 1920’s and
30’s, not that long ago. On that
side trip, we also had a stop at the Brindavan Gardens where we had High Tea on
the hotel terrace near the Krishnarajasagar Dam and its enormous lake.
Below the dam lay the exquisitely designed gardens with bright flowers
and silvery fountains. We were at the gardens in time to overlook the lake during a
beautiful sunset. Later we strolled
through the hundreds of illuminated fountains and pools.
- That is 30! A
TALE OF SUCCESS Bangalore India
Motorcycle Hemet Law This is a
tale about how the state of Kamataka, India obtained their law to mandate the
use of safety helmets for motorcycle drivers.
“It required getting fed up with the daily carnage we were seeing”,
said Dr. R. M. Varma, a neurologist who lives in Banglaore, India.
“A group of us got together and wrote a proposed law which would
require all motorcycle riders wear a second skull – a safety helmet”, Varma
added. This group
submitted their proposal to the state governor, where the proposal sat and
gathered dust for over five years. Varma
and his associates kept gathering statistics about the observable facts of
motorcycle use – the deaths and the injury that resulted from their use.
During their wait, the helmet-use advocates observed a 50% increase in
the number of accidents. Eight to
ten motorcycle riders were dying each month; 140 to 180 were being injured.
They also learned that the death rate for 2-wheeler riders who had
received a head injury during an accident was 6.8% if wearing a helmet, and was
twice that (13.5%) if they shunned the safety device. Bangalore
is the capital of the state of Karnataka and has a population of about
4,000,000. There are about 700,000
vehicles registered within the city. “Two-wheelers”,
as motorcycles are known in India, account for 75% of these vehicles. The
proposed helmet law just sat there. “No
one wants to wear a helmet”, they were told.
Most of the police did not like it, the transportation department did not
support it, and none of the politicians would touch it. In 1990,
Dr. Varma and his family traveled to northern India for a vacation.
Upon arriving, he was greeted by the local police who carried an urgent
message that he was needed back in Bangalore.
Their police convoy rushed the doctor to a nearby airport where he
boarded a small plane for a flight to New Delhi. As he
neared Delhi, he learned that the flight to Bangalore was being held, awaiting
his arrival. At Bangalore, he
received another police escort to a hospital room where a young man lay with a
cracked skull from a motorcycle accident. Varma lost
no time in examining the injured lad and after completing his diagnosis,
prescribed some additional treatment measures.
Then, doctor Varma mustered up the energy to face the hardest task of
all, a task he had already performed dozens of other times that year.
He then retired to the adjoining room in order to speak to the parents of
the young man. The room this time was very crowded. He recognized some of those present – the mayor of
Bangalore, the chief police inspector, the state governor, and the Vice
President of India. This boy was
the Vice President’s son. This time,
Varma was able to tell the eager audience and the Vice President that his boy
was stable, that he had a cracked skull, and numerous contusions, but he had
been lucky. The damage to his brain
appeared to be minimal and with time he should fully recover. As Varma prepared to leave, the Governor of the state come
over to him and said, “Doctor,
Varma, is there anything I can do for you?” “Three
things”, Varma immediately
blurted out. “First!
Approve our proposal that all motorcycle riders be required to wear
safety helmets.” “Second”,
he continued, “build a trauma center here in Bangalore so that we may
adequately treat persons with these types of injuries”.
“And third”, he said with a smile, “return me to my vacation with
the same dispatch that you brought me here”. And six
hours later Dr. Varma was again with his family, two months later the state
government approved the law Varma cherished, and two years later Varma assisted
in the opening of a trauma center within the city of Bangalore. The deadly pneumonic plague in
India is a health official’s nightmare. This
plague is known to be caused by a bacterium infection, and also to be
transmitted by plague infected fleas that are transported around by infected
rats. Like
the venerated cows of India, rats are also treated as a god by
many of the country’s 740 million Hindus and are allowed free rein in
many Indian households. At some temples of the country, the effort to stifle the
outbreak of pneumonic plague took a back seat to an old Hindu practice - rat
worship. It seems that according to
Hindu whenever and wherever the god Ganesh travels. Most
Hindu worship services are not complete without an offering to Ganesh
and his small friend. It
has been estimated by numerous researchers that rats consume nearly one-quarter
of the produce raised by India farmers. If
this is so, it would be enough food
to feed the entire 900 million population of India for three full months.
Yet rats are protected and rarely killed as it is considered by the Hindu
religion to be a sin to kill an associate of their god.
It is not expected that even the pneumonic plague will change this
ancient religion-based tradition of venerating rats in India. November
1994
|
Type what you want here to show on every webpage, or just delete this text. |